Have ESG management systems failed to recognise Russia’s risks?

The current war in Ukraine has opened the debate about responsible investment managers current and future exposures in Russia. Similar to the 2008 financial crisis, when Lehman Brothers’ rating was still investment grade just days before its collapse, many ESG data analytics firms downgraded Russia only after the crisis escalated – thus failing to adequately identify ESG risks. Indeed, data shows that ESG funds had USD 8.3 billion in Russian assets right before the war in Ukraine.(1) However, not all fund managers integrate ESG considerations in the same way. The key difference is in how they construct their portfolio, i.e. whether they passively track an index or actively select investments based on their own research. Therefore, the answer to the question is yes and no.

While passive ESG integration relies on third-party indexes to screen companies for compliance with various ESG criteria, active ESG integration implies conducting their own research to identify investments that meet their criteria. If we look at the current allegations related to Russia, most of them are related to passively managed ESG funds.

Active ESG management can be game-changing

BlueOrchard, for example, takes an active approach to assessing ESG risks. This has resulted in investments in Russia being off the table for years – mainly because of very high ESG risks in the country due to significant political and governance concerns. While at BlueOrchard we rely on reputable external sources to provide information on ESG risks, the analysis is ultimately conducted internally. One of the main pillars of B.Impact, our proprietary impact management and measurement framework, is an ESG assessment based primarily on ESG questionnaires completed by the companies in which we invest, inputs from our impact management team, from our investment teams during on-site due diligences, and discussions with various stakeholders.

Excluding investments in certain regions or countries is never an easy decision. As impact investors, we seek to generate and promote positive environmental and social change in emerging and frontier markets, where development gaps are larger, and exclusion is greatest. Deep knowledge and understanding of the markets, including ESG considerations, are paramount. In certain circumstances, the ESG risks may be so high that the likelihood of a positive impact is reduced.

In Russia, the lack of effective supervision and regulation and the extremely high probability of exposure to financial crime and KYC (Know Your Customer) issues have made the market untenable for BlueOrchard since 2014.

Our assessment of country risk and investment readiness of markets and companies is an ongoing process and while we do not take decisions lightly, we often see changes over time. The vast majority of our investment professionals are based locally in our emerging markets offices and we work closely together to ensure we can respond quickly to any developments at country, regulatory, and company level.

(1) ESG Funds Had $8.3 Billion in Russia Assets Just Before War – Bloomberg


– ends –


For further information, please contact:
Tahmina Theis
+41 44 441 55 50



The information in this publication was produced by BlueOrchard Finance Ltd (“BOF”) to the best of its present knowledge and belief. However, all data and financial information provided is on an unaudited and “as is” basis. The opinions expressed in this publication are those of BOF and its employees and are subject to change at any time without notice. BOF provides no guarantee with regard to the accuracy and completeness of the content in this publication. BOF does not in any way ascertain that the statements concerning future developments will be correct. BOF does not under any circumstance accept liability for any losses or damages which may arise from making use of, or relying upon any information, content or opinion provided by BOF in this publication. This publication is provided for marketing reasons and is not to be seen as investment research. As such it is not prepared pursuant legal requirements established for the promotion of independent investment research nor subject to any prohibition on dealing ahead of the distribution of investment research. This publication may contain information, references or links to other publications and websites from external sources. BOF has not reviewed such other publications and websites. BOF in particular does neither guarantee that such information is complete, accurate and up-to-date nor is BOF responsible in any way in relation to the content of such publications and websites. The information in this publication is the sole property of BOF unless otherwise noted, and may not be reproduced in full or in part without the express prior written consent of BOF. All investments involve risk. We note specifically that past performance is not an indication of future results. Emerging markets impact investments involve a unique and substantial level of risk that is critical to understand before engaging in any prospective relationship with BOF and its various managed funds. Investments in emerging markets, particularly those involving foreign currencies, may present significant additional risk and in all cases the risks implicated in this disclaimer include the risk of loss of invested capital. To understand specific risks of an investment, please refer to the currently valid legal investment documentation. The materials provided in this publication are for informational purposes only and nothing in this publication can be construed as constituting any offer to purchase any product, or a recommendation/solicitation or other inducement to buy or sell any financial instrument of any kind and shall not under any circumstances be construed as absolving any reader of this publication of his/her responsibility for making an independent evaluation of the risks and potential rewards of any financial transaction. We note in particular that none of the investment products referred to in this publication constitute securities registered under the Securities Act of 1933 (of the United States of America) and BOF and its managed/advised funds are materially limited in their capacity to sell any financial products of any kind in the United States. No investment product referenced in this publication may be publicly offered for sale in the United States and nothing in this publication shall be construed under any circumstances as a solicitation of a US Person (as defined in applicable law/regulation) to purchase any BOF investment product. The information provided in this publication is intended for review and receipt only by those persons who are qualified (in accordance with applicable legal/regulatory definitions) in their respective place of residence and/or business to view it, and the information is not intended under any circumstances to be provided to any person who is not legally eligible to receive it. Any recipient of information from this publication who wishes to engage with BOF in furtherance of any transaction or any relationship whatsoever must consult his/her own tax, legal and investment professionals to determine whether such relationship and/or transaction is suitable. By no means is the information provided in this document aimed at persons who are residents of any country where the product mentioned herein is not registered or approved for sale or marketing or in which dissemination of such information is not permitted. Persons who are not qualified to obtain such publication are kindly requested to discard it or return it to the sender. BOF disclaims all liability for any direct or indirect damages and/or costs that may arise from the use of (whether such use is proper or improper), or access to, this publication (or the inability to access this publication). BOF has outsourced the provision of IT services (operation of data centers, data storage, etc.) to Schroders group companies in Switzerland and abroad. A sub-delegation to third parties including cloud-computing service providers is possible. The regulatory bodies and the audit company took notice of the outsourcing and the data protection and regulatory requirements are observed.

Copyright © 2022, BlueOrchard Finance Ltd. All rights reserved.